45 Comments

Oh my, what a layer of story here. Amongst the ruin, so much love and space holding. Knowing these things about you and your mama makes me think, if course, this is why Brooke is who she is. What an amazing lineage she comes from. My deepest sympathy for the loss. But earth Mama and Angels made it through! Yay for that!

Expand full comment
author

❤️

Expand full comment

I have to move into long term care here in Ontario, Canada. Even though I’m only 74, a fall left me unable to walk and becoming incontinent. Twenty years ago I moved from a house to apartment but still had room for my journals and photos. This time I share a room and so have no space for those albums. I THOUGHT I needed them to write my memoir but your article reminded me that I still have the memories just not the physical reminders. Thanks, Brooke!

Expand full comment
author

So glad to hear this, Trudy—though I'm sorry about your fall and other challenges. Yes, keep writing. Yes to the memories.

Expand full comment

You remind me... In the 1980s, my parents, in their 70s, moved from Massachusetts to California. They flew; their belongings went in a huge Mayflower van. Along the way, it caught fire. What remained? Only the handful of family heirloom items, including photos, they'd managed to get out of Germany 50 years earlier and some irreplaceable books. Fire and destiny can intersect in inexplicable ways...

Expand full comment
author

So true about fire and any disaster, I suppose. We never know what will be on the other side. Thanks for this story, Jude.

Expand full comment

Heartbreaking. You asked us to share a legacy - my mother handed me a battered cardboard candy box with documents that detailed the history of my grandfather's suffering from PTSD. A story never told to the grandkids; - our parents didn't want us afraid of him. I'm working on a book that honors him and my grandmother who pulled him through.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for sharing and love that you're working on this project!

Expand full comment

The beauty which remains takes my breath away. Love and loss and lineage. This is some of the best writing of yours I ever read. Seriously, I felt this in my bones.

Expand full comment
author

Aw, thank you, Jill.

Expand full comment
Sep 22Liked by Brooke Warner

Brooke, my heart goes out to you and your mum! My husband I moved to Maine from Northern California due to the wildfire crisis. The trauma, to individual and communities, is so difficult for people to understand who have not gone through it. Wishing you the best, with much admiration for your work. ~ Liz

Expand full comment

Our legacy is handed down. So beautiful. I love the photographs you included. “Believe in People”. 🩷

Expand full comment
Sep 22·edited Sep 22Liked by Brooke Warner

So sad, and yet hopeful and full. Beautifully written. It reminds me of my mountain, St. Helens. I look at the photos of the time my family spent there in the 1950s and 60s and I remember visiting her in the early 80s—unrecognizable from my childhood memory (that does live on in my body, yes). I hike there now and watch the return of beauty of a different sort. Out of the ashes . . . That "believe in people" could be "believe in nature" at Mt. St. Helens. Thank you.

Expand full comment
author

Believe in nature. Yes. We have to treat her better, too. Thanks, Gretchen.

Expand full comment

Brooke, this brought tears. I felt the love of your mom, her aunt and uncle, and you. I live in a fire zone (Montana) but have not yet experienced one close to our property. But I felt a lot of vicarious trauma from the news coming out of the Paradise fire some years ago. It was all I thought and prayed about for months. Then the Maui fire. ugh. But your love and gratitude shines much light. I've never forgotten hour kindness to me as you helped me with my memoir before I became sick again. I'm still here! (and write on Substack). Thank you for being you. Much love.

Expand full comment
author

Good to see you here, Linda. Thanks for your comment and your kindness here, too.

Expand full comment
24 hrs agoLiked by Brooke Warner

What a beautifully written, touching and personal piece from you, Brooke. How fortunate you've been to have such an inspiring mother---a leader in creating home and community. And how fortunate she is to have you for a daughter, a force of love and support to others. My grandmother fled Eastern Europe during the pogroms of the early 1900s. She boarded a ship to Canada with one little son, a baby in arms, and a husband who was so clueless that when she told him to take care of the diapers he threw them out the ship's portal window. She took only one thing from her family home: a pair of brass Shabbat candlesticks, which my mother owned and now I do, but my grandmother's greatest legacy was her strength and determination to thrive. She started a little grocery store in downtown Los Angeles that later supported the family, and in turn my mother had a 40 year career as a fine artist. In past eras when self-reliance, higher education for girls and creating our own income were decades away, my grandmother's resourcefulness and resilience were handed down to my mother and then to us. This precious legacy is symbolized for me in those two, sturdy candlesticks that shine on my dining room table. Out of the ashes, something new will grow...

Expand full comment
author

I love this story, Bonnie. Thanks for sharing. You are a lineage of resilient women, indeed!

Expand full comment

Brooke, the whole piece is so heartful, but the images combined with the words moved me the most. So. Much. Tenderness.

Expand full comment

This is a heartbreaking post, Brooke. At the same time it gives us a beautiful and inspiring glimpse into your world and your lineage, and the vision and wisdom of your mom. The images are powerful and telling, and I am glad you were able to rescue some meaningful relics. I agree with all that @dhanamusil said 🪽

Expand full comment
Sep 22Liked by Brooke Warner

Brooke, such a beautiful essay and tribute to your mom and Pine Manor. Thank you for sharing your heart and your wisdom.

Expand full comment

Big love to you and your family, Brooke. My heart goes out to all of you. Such a beautiful tribute to the connections between us all. 💕

Expand full comment

My heart breaks for your loss and I understand the gratitude you feel in the face of such a loss. The things that remain now carry with them all of what was there before. Sending love & strength. xo

Expand full comment

What a story, Brooke! You bring such meaning to this story. I'm so glad to hear that no one was hurt and that precious mementoes were recovered. When I lived in an apt in Seattle, there was a fire that destroyed everything, including some priceless porcelain pieces that I have never forgotten. But I am so glad to see the precious figures found in the ash, the symbol of a phoenix rising if ever there was on. Thank you for sharing this story, I'll be sending it on to our family members who survived the fire at my grandparents farmhouse.

Expand full comment